Question
Does Islam prohibit women from being a ruler or holding positions of leadership such as the head of state? Many people cite the hadith: “People who appoint a woman as their leader will never succeed.” Others say that a man is the head of the family, so only a man can be the head of state. Are these arguments sound?
Answer
Many Muslim scholars hold that a woman cannot be head of state in Islam. Most of them base this view on one ḥadīth. A ḥadīth is a report of what the Prophet (sws) said or did. Some also argue from the family. A man heads the family, they say, so a man must head the state.
In our understanding, neither argument proves the point. The Qur’ān makes consultation the basis of government. It does not exclude women from it. The Qur’ān also tells the story of a woman ruler, the Queen of Sabā (Sheba). It does not blame her for ruling. As for the ḥadīth, it has serious weaknesses, and it can be read as a word about Persia alone.
The ḥadīth that is cited
عن أبي بَكْرَةَ قال لقد نَفَعَنِي الله بِكَلِمَةٍ سَمِعْتُهَا من رسول اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم أَيَّامَ الْجَمَلِ بَعْدَ ما كِدْتُ أَنْ أَلْحَقَ بِأَصْحَابِ الْجَمَلِ فَأُقَاتِلَ مَعَهُمْ قال لَمَّا بَلَغَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم أَنَّ أَهْلَ فَارِسَ قد مَلَّكُوا عليهم بِنْتَ كِسْرَى قال لَنْ يُفْلِحَ قَوْمٌ وَلَّوْا أَمْرَهُمْ امْرَأَةً
Abū Bakrah reported: “Allah has given me the benefit of a word – which I heard from the Messenger of Allah – during the days of [the battle of] al-Jamal when I was about to join the people of al-Jamal and fight alongside them: when the Messenger of Allah heard that the people of Persia had appointed the daughter of Chosroes, he said: ‘People who appoint a woman as their leader will never succeed.’”
(Bukhārī, no. 4425)
Bukhārī gives the same report again (no. 7099). Tirmidhī also has it (no. 2262). Read as a general rule, it would bar women from leading any nation at any time. There are four reasons why it cannot carry such a rule.1
Why this report cannot settle the question
1. It came to light late, in a political dispute. Abū Bakrah (rta) himself says that he recalled these words in the days of the Battle of the Camel (al-Jamal). This battle took place in 36 AH. In it, ‘Ā’ishah (rta) and her supporters faced the army of ‘Alī (rta). The Prophet (sws) had spoken these words more than twenty-five years before. Yet we do not find the report mentioned before this battle. It was first brought forward when the dispute was at its height.
The report does not even fit that case. ‘Ā’ishah (rta) never claimed to be the ruler of the Muslims.
2. Only one Companion reports it. In ḥadīth terms, a report with only one narrator at some stage of its chain is called gharīb (solitary).2 This report reaches us through one Companion only, Abū Bakrah (rta). Yet it speaks of a matter of great public weight. If the Prophet (sws) had given such a rule for all Muslims, other Companions should also have known it and passed it on. We find none who did. A solitary report can explain what is already in the Qur’ān and the Sunnah. (The Sunnah is the religious practice that the Prophet (sws) set up among his followers.) On its own, such a report cannot set a new rule for whole societies.3
3. As a general rule, it does not fit history. Many nations had women rulers before the Prophet (sws) and after him. Many of these nations did well. The Qur’ān itself tells of one, as we shall see below. So if these words are taken as a general rule, they do not match the facts. Either they were not meant as a general rule, or they have not reached us as they were said.
4. As a general rule, it goes against the Qur’ān. The Qur’ān makes consultation the basis of a Muslim government. It does not exclude women from this. We explain this further below.
A word about Persia
Suppose the Prophet (sws) did say these words. We must still ask what he meant. The setting of the report helps here.
Bukhārī places this report in his chapter on the Prophet’s letters to Chosroes (Kisrā), the king of Persia, and to Caesar. The report just before it tells us that Chosroes tore up the Prophet’s letter. One of its narrators adds that the Prophet (sws) then prayed that the Persian rulers be torn apart completely (Bukhārī, no. 4424). Tirmidhī’s version of our report gives one more detail. Chosroes had died, and the Prophet (sws) asked whom the Persians had put in his place. He was told: his daughter (Tirmidhī, no. 2262).
Read in this setting, the words are about the Persian kingdom. Its king had rejected the message of God’s Messenger. Its power was already breaking up. The words foretold where this would end. And so it happened. Within a few years, the Persian armies were defeated. Within about twenty years, the empire had come to an end.
The Qur’ān and the ḥadīth often use general words about a particular event. These words, too, can be read as a statement about one nation at one time. Read in this way, they agree with the Qur’ān. Read as a rule that women may never lead, they clash with it. When a report can be understood in harmony with the Qur’ān, that is how it should be understood.3
A woman ruler in the Qur’ān: the Queen of Sheba
The Qur’ān tells the story of a woman who ruled a nation. She was the Queen of Sabā (Sheba), in the time of the Prophet Solomon (sws). Her story is in Sūrah al-Naml (27:20–44). Nowhere does the Qur’ān suggest that she was unfit to rule. It shows her as a wise ruler.
The story begins when a bird, the hudhud, brings Solomon (sws) news of her4:
I saw a woman ruling them; all types of means and resources are available to her and she also has a very large throne. I have seen her and her nation prostrating before the sun. Satan has made their deeds look fair to them and has stopped them from the right path; so, they are not finding the way.
(27:23–24)
The bird’s report finds fault with one thing only: she and her nation worshipped the sun. It finds no fault with a woman ruling them. It also says that her kingdom had every kind of means and resources.
Solomon (sws) then sent them a letter. It said: “Do not show rebelliousness against me and come to me in obedience” (27:31). It did not ask her to give up her rule.
When the letter came, she did not decide alone. She asked her courtiers for their opinion:
The queen said: “Courtiers! Give your opinion in this matter of mine. [You know that] I do not decide any matter unless you people are present before me.” They replied: “We are powerful and also have great military might. So, the decision is now in your hands. Thus see what directive you may give.”
(27:32–33)
Her courtiers spoke of their military might. They were ready for war. But she saw further:
The queen said: “When kings enter a city [after conquering it], they ravage it and humiliate the honourable in it, and these people will also do the same. [My opinion is that] I send a delegation to him with gifts; then see what reply my envoys bring back.”
(27:34–35)
She knew what war would bring on her people: ruin and humiliation. So, before any fighting began, she chose to test Solomon’s intent through gifts and envoys.5 In the end, she went to meet Solomon (sws) herself. There she saw the truth and accepted it:
Lord! I have remained unjust to myself. [So, I repent] and with Solomon I have consigned myself to God, Lord of the worlds.
(27:44)
The Qur’ān also tells us what had kept her from faith before this:
In reality [she would have believed earlier but] those things stopped her which she worshipped besides God because she was from a disbelieving nation.
(27:43)
What held her back was the religion of her nation. It was not that she was a woman. Leaving the ways of one’s nation is hard for anyone. It is hardest for those who lead it.6 Yet she left them.
So the Qur’ān tells of a woman ruler who had a rich kingdom. She sought advice. She avoided a needless war. In the end, she submitted to God. Nowhere does the Qur’ān say that she should not have ruled. Nor does it say that Solomon (sws) took her rule from her.7
The same sūrah begins with another ruler, the Pharaoh. He and his people saw God’s signs. Of them the Qur’ān says: “They rejected them because of injustice and arrogance, even though their hearts had accepted these signs” (27:14). The sūrah thus sets two rulers side by side.8 The Pharaoh chose arrogance, and it ruined his people. The queen chose peace and, in the end, faith.
The Queen of Sheba in the Bible
The Bible tells the same story more briefly (1 Kings 10:1–13; 2 Chronicles 9:1–12). It does not speak of her courtiers or of Solomon’s letter. But it adds three details.
First, she came to Jerusalem to test Solomon’s wisdom with hard questions. When she heard his answers, she praised God:
Blessed be the LORD thy God, which delighted in thee, to set thee on the throne of Israel: because the LORD loved Israel for ever, therefore made he thee king, to do judgment and justice.
(1 Kings 10:9)
She saw kingship as a trust from God for doing justice.
Second, after her visit she went back to her own country with her servants (1 Kings 10:13). Nothing suggests that she lost her throne.
Third, according to the Gospels, Jesus (sws) praised her. He held her up as an example to the people of his time, who would not listen to him:
The queen of the south shall rise up in the judgment with this generation, and shall condemn it: for she came from the uttermost parts of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon; and, behold, a greater than Solomon is here.
(Matthew 12:42; see also Luke 11:31)
So the Bible, too, presents her as a ruler who sought wisdom and honoured God. (The Bible verses are quoted from the King James Version.)
Men of power who ruined their nations
The Qur’ān speaks often of nations that were destroyed. Again and again, it traces their ruin to their leaders. It states this as a law of God:
When We intend to destroy a settlement [because of its misdeeds], We direct its affluent: “Go and do whatever you want to.” Then they continue to show defiance in it; after that, the word is fulfilled for that settlement and We totally ravage it.
(17:16)
The clearest example is the Pharaoh. The Qur’ān says of him:
So, he fooled his nation and they were lured by him. Indeed, they were a disobedient people.
(43:54)
… they obeyed what the Pharaoh said even though what he said was not correct. On the Day of Judgement, he will be in front of his people and will lead them to Hell.
(11:97–98)
It also says that the Pharaoh “had but led astray his nation” (20:79). The people of Noah (sws) followed leaders “whose wealth and children have only added to their ruin” (71:21). In every town to which God sent a warner, its wealthy were the first to reject him (34:34). On the Day of Judgement, those who followed such leaders will say:
Our Lord! we listened to our leaders and to our elders; so, they misled us.
(33:67)
The leaders the Qur’ān names in these accounts are men. Yet the Qur’ān never says that a nation led by a man will fail. It blames these rulers for their arrogance, their injustice and their rejection of the truth. It does not blame them for being men. In the same way, its one detailed account of a woman ruler does not blame her for being a woman. It shows her good sense.
So what decides the fate of a nation is the character and conduct of those who lead it. Whether the ruler is a man or a woman does not decide it.
The Qur’ān’s principle: government by consultation
The Qur’ān describes the believers in these words:
وَأَمْرُهُمْ شُورَى بَيْنَهُمْ
… and their system is based on their mutual consultation …
(42:38)
The Arabic word for consultation here is shūrā. This verse means that a Muslim government should be formed with the consent of the majority. It should stay in office as long as it keeps this consent. It should step down when it loses it.9
The verse speaks of the believers as a whole, men and women alike. Nowhere does the Qur’ān exclude women from this principle. So if a woman wins the trust of the majority in a country, it is the will of the majority that she should lead it. That will should be followed.
The family and the state
Some argue from the family. Islam makes the man the head of the family. The family is the basic unit of society. So, they say, only a man can head the state.
But the family and the state are run on different grounds. About the family, the Qur’ān says:
[On the basis of this very principle, in the husband-wife relationship also] men are made in charge of women because God has given one superiority over the other, and because they have spent their wealth.
(4:34)
The verse speaks of the husband-wife relationship. It gives two grounds for the husband’s charge. First, men in general are better suited to this role by temperament and physical strength. Second, they have been given the duty of earning for the family.
The head of state is chosen on a different ground: the trust of the majority, as 42:38 requires. Since the grounds are different, a rule for one cannot be drawn from the other by analogy.10
How Muslim scholars have differed
Most classical jurists, citing this ḥadīth, held that a woman may not hold rule (imārah) or serve as a judge. Above all, they held that she could not be the caliph, the single ruler of the Muslim world.11 But from early times, jurists differed on how far the ḥadīth reaches.
- In the school of Imām Abū Ḥanīfah, a woman’s judgment as a judge is valid in all cases where her testimony is accepted. This leaves out cases of ḥudūd (fixed punishments for certain crimes) and qiṣāṣ (retaliation for murder or injury). Some Ḥanafī jurists add that it is wrong to appoint her, but her judgments still stand.12
- Imām Ibn Ḥazm, in al-Muḥallā, allowed a woman to serve as a judge. He applied this ḥadīth to the caliphate, not to the office of judge. He also cites a report that ‘Umar (rta) put a woman, al-Shifā’, in charge of the market.13
- Ibn Ḥajar reports that Imām Ibn Jarīr al-Ṭabarī allowed a woman to hold rule as well as to serve as a judge. He adds that this is also one narration from Imām Mālik. 14
- Some Mālikī jurists, too, allowed women to serve as judges without any limit. The main view of the Mālikī school is against this.15
These jurists were speaking of the caliphate as it was known in their time: one ruler over the whole Muslim world, usually for life. A head of state today is chosen for a fixed term. He or she governs under a constitution and shares power with a parliament and courts. So the classical views about the caliphate do not, on their own, settle the question of a head of state today.16
In closing
- The ḥadīth cited against women rulers came to light late. It comes through one Companion only. As a general rule, it does not fit history.
- Read in its setting, it can be understood as a word about the fall of the Persian kingdom. It need not be a rule for all nations.
- The Qur’ān tells of the Queen of Sheba. It does not fault her for ruling. It shows her as wise, careful to avoid war, and ready to accept the truth. The Bible adds that Jesus (sws) praised her.
- The Qur’ān traces the ruin of nations to arrogant and unjust leaders. The leaders it names are men. Yet it never blames their ruin on their being men.
- The Qur’ān makes consultation the basis of government. It does not exclude women from it.
- The rule for the head of a family cannot be carried over to the head of state. The two are chosen on different grounds.
- Muslim jurists have differed on women in public office since the early centuries.
In our understanding, then, the Qur’ān does not bar a woman from being head of state and a hadith report is not sufficient to establish a religious prohibition. Readers may weigh the arguments and reach their own view.
Notes
- Shehzad Saleem, Islam and Women: Misconceptions and Misperceptions (Lahore: Al-Mawrid, 2005), 11–13. The four reasons follow this book. The English rendering of the ḥadīth is also taken from it (pp. 11–12). Three of the reasons appear in his answer “Can a Woman Become a Head of State,” Renaissance.
- Ibn al-Ṣalāḥ, Muqaddimah (Beirut: Dār al-Fikr, 1977), 270, cited in Saleem, Islam and Women, 13, n. 7.
- Javed Ahmad Ghamidi, Islam: A Comprehensive Introduction, an English rendering of Mīzān by Shehzad Saleem (2021 printing), 19 (reports about the Prophet (sws) cannot add to the beliefs and practices of religion; they explain it) and 67 (a solitary report that goes against the Qur’ān is not accepted, a view he also cites from al-Khaṭīb al-Baghdādī).
- All Qur’ān quotations are from Javed Ahmad Ghamidi, The Qur’ān Translated, tr. Shehzad Saleem.
- Javed Ahmad Ghamidi, Al-Bayān, “Sūrah al-Naml,” tr. Shehzad Saleem, Renaissance, nn. 42–43 (on 27:33–35). Amīn Aḥsan Iṣlāḥī, Tadabbur-i Qur’ān, “Sūrah al-Naml (1),” tr. Shehzad Saleem, Renaissance, September 2021, on 27:34–35.
- Ghamidi, Al-Bayān, “Sūrah al-Naml,” n. 52 (on 27:43); Iṣlāḥī, “Sūrah al-Naml (1),” on 27:43.
- Iṣlāḥī, “Sūrah al-Naml (1),” on 27:44. He rejects the stories that Solomon (sws) married her and holds that she went back to rule her land. Ghamidi, Al-Bayān, “Sūrah al-Naml,” n. 54, refers to the Bible’s account of her return home.
- Iṣlāḥī, “Sūrah al-Naml (2),” tr. Shehzad Saleem, Renaissance, October 2021, 7. He sums up the earlier verses as accounts of “the Pharaoh’s rebelliousness, Solomon’s gratitude and uprightness of the queen of Sabā.”
- Saleem, Islam and Women, 13; Ghamidi, Islam: A Comprehensive Introduction, 456–457 (the head of state is chosen through consultation, all have an equal right in it, and the majority view decides). That 42:38 is not limited to men is also noted in “Women’s role in political affairs in early Islam” on this site.
- Saleem, Islam and Women, 13–14; and his answer “An Objection to Women Heading a State,” Renaissance.
- Ibn Ḥajar, Fatḥ al-Bārī, 8:128 (on no. 4425), calls barring women from rule and judgeship “the view of the majority”. On the caliphate, see also Ibn Ḥazm, al-Muḥallā, masʾalah 1774, which cites this ḥadīth.
- Al-Marghīnānī, al-Hidāyah, Kitāb adab al-qāḍī; Ibn al-Humām, Fatḥ al-Qadīr, on the same passage.
- Ibn Ḥazm, al-Muḥallā, masʾalah 1774 (the caliphate), and his discussion of judges, where he cites the report about ‘Umar (rta) and al-Shifā’.
- Ibn Ḥajar, Fatḥ al-Bārī, 8:128 (al-Ṭabarī, and one narration from Mālik, allow her to hold rule and judgeship) and 13:56 (quoting Ibn al-Tīn: al-Ṭabarī allows her to judge where her testimony is accepted). Ibn Rushd, Bidāyat al-mujtahid, Kitāb al-aqḍiyah, reports al-Ṭabarī as allowing her to judge in all matters. Ibn al-ʿArabī, Aḥkām al-Qur’ān, 3:482, says the report about al-Ṭabarī is not sound.
- Ibn al-Tīn, quoted in Ibn Ḥajar, Fatḥ al-Bārī, 13:56.
- A similar distinction is drawn by Dār al-Iftā’ al-Miṣriyyah, “Women as Heads of State.”
Answered by: Mushfiq Sultan
Have a follow-up question about this answer?
Ask a follow-up







One response to “Does Islam prohibit women from holding leadership positions?”
Al hamdu lil lah very well explained.
/
/