Does Qur’an 4:11 really contain a mathematical error with inheritance distribution?


Wooden family figures and house with keys on table

Question

I recently came across an issue often highlighted by atheists regarding Qur’an’s distribution of inheritance.
The error is that when we do the distribution of wealth according to surah 4 verse 11, the required amount for redistribution exceeds the total wealth available.
Scenario:
Let’s say a man passed away, leaving both parents, 2+ daughters, and a wife. The amount of money/property each person/group would inherit would then be:
2/3 for the daughters split amongst each other
1/8 for the wife
1/6 for mother
1/6 for father
Suppose man leaves Rs 100 rupees at the time of his death
2/3 for daughters = 66.66
1/8 for wife = 12.5
1/6 for mother = 16.66
1/6 for father = 16.66
The total becomes: 66.66+12.5+16.66+16.66 = 112.48
This clearly exceeds the available amount of Rs 100.
Please answer this issue.

Answer

On this issue, our understanding is that Muslim scholars have generally misinterpreted the method of distributing the inheritance. 

The objection raised adds four fractions together: two-thirds, one-eighth, one-sixth and one-sixth. It assumes that all four are fractions of the same whole estate. The verse does not say that. Once the verse is read in its own order, the shares never exceed the estate.

What the verse says

God directs you regarding your children that among them a boy’s share is equal to that of two girls’. Then, if there are only girls among the children and they are two or more than two, then they shall be given two-thirds of the inheritance, and, if there is only one girl, then her share is one-half. But a sixth of the inheritance [before this] should be given to each of the parents of the deceased if he has children … (4:11)

The next verse gives the share of wives. “They” here means the wives:

And if you have children, then they shall inherit one-eighth of what you leave, after execution of any will you may have bequeathed, and after discharging any [outstanding] debts. (4:12)

How the verse is built

1. The children are the main heirs. The verse opens with the children. It does not give them a fraction. It gives a ratio: a boy receives twice what a girl receives. A ratio with no fraction means that the estate as such belongs to the children.

2. The parents and the spouse are then taken out of it. After the children, the verse says “But a sixth … should be given to each of the parents”. The next verse gives the husband or wife a share in the same way. These sentences amend the first one. They are not a second, separate list.

An everyday example shows this. Suppose someone says: “This money is for the children. Each boy gets twice as much as a girl. And give the father half of it.” Every listener understands the order. The father’s half is taken out first. The children then divide what is left. Nobody thinks that the children take the whole amount and the father then takes another half.

3. The daughters’ two-thirds is part of the children’s rule. The words “if there are only girls … they shall be given two-thirds” are an exception inside the rule about children. They explain what happens when there is no son. So this clause follows the same order as the rest of the rule. The parents and the spouse are paid first. The daughters then receive two-thirds, or one-half for a single daughter, of what remains.

A second example makes the point. “ʿUmar, ʿAlī and Saʿīd have equal shares in this amount. If only ʿAlī and Saʿīd are present, ʿAlī gets two-thirds and Saʿīd one-third. And give ten rupees from it to their sister.” The ten rupees go to the sister first. The two-thirds and one-third are then worked out on the rest.

In this reading, the parents and the spouse receive their shares from the whole estate. The children receive theirs from the remainder. If there are sons, or sons and daughters, they divide the whole remainder. If there are only daughters, they receive two-thirds or one-half of the remainder.

The same case, worked out

Take the example you gave. A man leaves Rs 100. His heirs are a wife, a mother, a father and two or more daughters. Debts and any bequest have already been paid.

StepHeirShareAmount (Rs)
1Wife1/8 of the estate12.50
1Mother1/6 of the estate16.67
1Father1/6 of the estate16.67

Paid so far
45.83

Remainder
54.17
2Daughters, together2/3 of the remainder36.11

Total given as fixed shares
81.94

Left over
18.06

The total is Rs 81.94. It is less than Rs 100, not more.

What happens to the amount left over

The verse itself gives the principle. It says the shares rest on who is “the nearest to you in benefit”. In a hadith report attributed to the Prophet Muhammad (sws), he applied this principle in his time to any amount left over as follows:

Give the heirs their share and if something remains, it is for the closest male [relative]. (Bukhārī, no. 6732; Muslim, no. 1615)

In the case above, the closest male relative is the father. So the Rs 18.06 goes to him, unless the deceased had assigned it to someone in his will.

Where the objection comes from

The total of 112.5 per cent appears only when the daughters’ two-thirds is taken from the whole estate. Muslim Jurists who read the verse that way had to deal with cases where the fractions passed one whole. Their solution was ʿawl. ʿAwl means reducing every share in the same proportion until the total fits the estate. It is a rule made by jurists. It is not in the Qur’an.

So the difficulty lies in one way of reading the verse. It does not lie in the verse. When the verse is read in the order in which it speaks, each fraction is given exactly as stated, and no reduction is needed.

Further readings and resources

I hope this helps.

Regards,

Mushfiq Sultan
Assistant Fellow, Al-Mawrid

Have a follow-up question about this answer?

Ask a follow-up

Mushfiq Sultan Avatar